Update 3: Sebastian Montes’ story from last Wednesday has been fleshed out a little for the Friday edition of the Gazette; it now includes a report of the dust-up between Mike Stumborg & David Rocha:
As Olde Towne resident Lauren Husted thanked the city for ‘‘taking this bold step,” the Rev. David Rocha of Camino de Vida, a day-laborer advocate, stood behind her in line holding a sign that read ‘‘To Work is Not a Crime.”
He held it high and close behind her as she spoke.
Sitting nearby, Stumborg rose and ripped the sign away from Rocha, who turned and smiled his response: ‘‘I forgive you.”
Stumborg then called Rocha a derogatory name.
Mayor Sidney A. Katz urged calm, and the tension passed, but speaking a few moments later, the Rev. Simon Bautista, who is assigned to Episcopal Church of the Ascension, said he worried that the exchange could be a harbinger of things to come if the city were to pass the law.
‘‘We have just seen here a piece of what is going to happen … the hate getting into our hearts as we lose control of our emotions,” he said.
But Bob Drzyzgula, another Olde Towne resident, saw it differently.
‘‘We just saw a demonstration of an inability to wait one’s turn, an inability to demonstrate respect for other peoples’ opinion,” he said. By holding up the sign, he said Rocha ‘‘was demonstrating his arrogance and his impatience.”
Drzyzgula added, ‘‘What I see in the anti-solicitation ordinance is an effort to ask people to not try to take over property that doesn’t belong to them. … I don’t see that this has anything to do with racism or hatred. I think it has to do with wanting to see public order restored.”
For what it’s worth, I do not recall, in all my years of watching and attending Gaithersburg Mayor and Council meetings, anything like what happened on Monday. While I’ve seen others bring various sorts of visual aids, holding up a placard to distract attention from another speaker is just not done. I think that it was another example of how some parts of our immigrant population appear to have great difficulty understanding and living by local customs and societal norms.
First, note that the City has posted the video of this meeting, as well as the outcomes document, which I’ll paste in below.
Once again, the meeting was dominated by the issues of day laborers and the anti-solicitation ordinance. CASA de Maryland was out in full force: Gustavo Torres, Kim Propeack and Melissa Crow were there, as well as other advocates including several members of the clergy: Rev. Simon Bautista, Msgr. Mark Brennan and David Rocha. CASA had brought several ostensible members of the day laborer community, many of whom could receive legal services from CASA de Maryland in exchange for this attendance.
During the public hearing on the anti-solicitation ordinance, a long line of advocates and interested individuals spoke against the proposed ordinance. Many of those speaking against the ordinance asserted, typically, that it was a racist or anti-immigrant law. Repeatedly we heard how the day laborers were just hard-working souls who were only trying to put bread on their family’s tables.
At one point, David Rocha found it necessary to wave a sign saying “to work is not a crime” behind an individual who was speaking in favor of the ordinance. Checking the TV monitor and seeing that not much of his sign was making it on to TV, he held it up higher and to the side. Another member of the audience, apparently frustrated with this demonstration of disrespect and impatience, came forward to yank the sign out of Mr. Rocha’s hand, throwing it onto the floor. This brought a strong rebuke from the Mayor, and pleased assurances of “forgiveness” from Mr. Rocha. Following this, Mr. Rocha and Rev. Bautista characterized the act as a demonstration of the sort of intolerance they are forced to deal with on a daily basis, but a later speaker characterized it as a demonstration of the unwillingness of the advocates and the laborers to wait their turn or show respect for the opinions of others.
In the end, the Council voted to hold the record open for thirty days, as would be usual following a public hearing such as this one. Anyone with thoughts regarding this ordinance is encouraged to communicate them to the City.
Other things to note in last night’s meeting include the bizarre appearance of former Mayoral candidate Austin Decker, who spoke at length about the dangers of “remote neural monitoring”. Decker, who was in fact not wearing a tinfoil hat, told of a patent held by Aris Mardirossian, developer of Crown Farm, and sometime inventor. The patent, #6011991, describes:
A system and method for enabling human beings to communicate by way of their monitored brain activity. The brain activity of an individual is monitored and transmitted to a remote location (e.g. by satellite). At the remote location, the monitored brain activity is compared with pre-recorded normalized brain activity curves, waveforms, or patterns to determine if a match or substantial match is found. If such a match is found, then the computer at the remote location determines that the individual was attempting to communicate the word, phrase, or thought corresponding to the matched stored normalized signal.
Mr. Decker, who seemed not to feel bound by the normal three minute time limit for public appearances, was warned repeatedly by the Mayor that his time was up and that he needed to step away from the podium. This went on for long enough that I was beginning to think that the police (and this would have been Chief Viverette, as she was pulling Council meeting duty last night) were going to have to forcibly remove Mr. Decker from the room. Luckily (or not, depending on how you like your entertainment) Mr. Decker finally relented.
Speaking of Chief Viverette, City Manager David Humpton announced that she would be retiring as of May of 2007. Mr. Humpton read a statement of tribute to Ms. Viverette, who received a standing ovation from the audience.
Update: As noted by MoCoProgressive, one other thing of note was something that appeared not to happen. Gustavo Torres, Executive Director of CASA de Maryland, seems to have declined to recite the Pledge of Allegiance. This reticence was first noted, to my knowledge, by speaker Susan Payne. You can draw your own conclusion on this by taking a close look at the video, although I don’t think that this is as conclusive as one might like. The Pledge is, of course, the first thing that happens in the meeting. It starts about one minute into the video. As you see the camera shot from behind the audience, Torres is sitting immediately to the right of the podium, in a brown jacket and with brown hair. While he does stand during the ceremony, it looks as if he does not participate.
Susan Payne’s time at the podium during public appearances begins at 43:00; the accusation is at 45:00.
While you’re watching, Austin Decker’s performance begins at about 30:20 into the video.
While finding these timings, I noted one other thing I neglected to mention: Dr. Jorge Ribas, a Gaithersburg businessman, founder and past president of the Maryland Hispanic Chamber of Commerce and current president of the Western Maryland Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, spoke forcefully in opposition to the anti-solicitation ordinance. Personally, I found this somewhat disappointing.
Update 2: The Gazette has posted Sebastian Montes’ report of the meeting on their website:
A revised version of the law included slight changes that repositioned the measure as public safety issue.
On Monday, it was described in a number of other ways, including un-American, a bold step, a pretext for discrimination, a hard choice city leaders must be willing to make, a disappointing legislative maneuver and ‘‘a stab in the back of multiculturalism.”
‘‘I see no character at all in this measure. I see bigotry,” said city resident Joe Schuler, who lives near the North Frederick Avenue parking lot where the day laborers gather.
Supporters of the law — six of the 32 who spoke — argued that it is simply a way to bring order to the chaos they say has become the norm.
‘‘Please pass this worthy and just law and end the nightmare that my neighborhood has endured for over a year now,” said Mike Stumborg, who also lives near the current gathering site in the Olde Towne historic district. ‘‘Because no one else was willing to sign up to let their neighborhood be destroyed by this activity doesn’t mean it’s fair to continue let our neighborhood bear the brunt of this problem.”
The following is taken from the City’s outcomes document:
City of Gaithersburg
AGENDA FOR A REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MONDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2006, 7:30 P.M.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Minutes of a Regular Meeting of the Mayor and City Council Held October 16, 2006
Background Material (pdf format)
Approved 3-0
Minutes of a Special Meeting of the Mayor and City
Council Held November 6, 2006
Background Material (pdf format)
Approved 3-0 (with revision on page 13)
APPOINTMENTS
Resolution
of the City Council Confirming Appointments and Reappointments to the Greater Historic District Committee, Environmental Affairs Committee, and Multicultural Affairs Committee
Background Material (pdf format)
Approved 3-0
PRESENTATIONS
City Manager’s Day Laborer Report
City Manager Humpton read the following statement:
“I don’t have a lot to report this evening. As you all know, we have asked Montgomery County to immediately begin a search for a location for an employment center in a heavy commercial or industrial location outside the City. County staff has indicated that they would be taking the next few weeks to review this issue before taking any action. I expect to hear back from them after that time.
I have also asked for an update on the County’s progress in terminating the lease at 17 North Frederick Avenue . In an email I received today, it does not appear that this has moved forward very much. I’m concerned that, with the transition to a new administration at the County, this could get lost in the shuffle. We will be asking County staff for regular updates and reporting back to you as we get more information.
PUBLIC HEARING
An Ordinance to Repeal and Reenact With Amendments Section 15-4 of the City Code, Entitled “Loitering,” so as to Clarify Existing Language With Regard To Prohibited Conduct, and Section 15-9, Entitled “Solicitation in Roadways,” so as to Expand the Applicability of the City’s Prohibition on Solicitation Specific to this Chapter
Background Material (pdf format)
Vote 3-0 to hold the Mayor and City Council record open for 30 days, December 20, 2006 , 5 p.m.
HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION
Approval of Minutes
- Minutes of a Historic District Commission Meeting Held October 9, 2006
- Minutes of a Historic District Commission Meeting Held November 6, 2006
Background Material (pdf format)
City Manager Humpton made the following statement:
“The HDC agenda for this evening includes the approval of minutes of the HDC meeting on October 9, 2006 . That meeting included a public hearing on HAWP - 37E . That public hearing was very detailed, including the history of the project and testimony regarding financial information. You received the minutes of the meeting very close to tonight’s meeting, and, given the detail, I wanted to be sure that the HDC members had ample opportunity to review the minutes prior to approving them. In addition, I have not had a chance to review the minutes and believe it is important to do so. Therefore, I am suggesting that the HDC defer action on the minutes of the October 9, 2006 meeting to the next meeting on December 4. Also, to try and approve the minutes in meeting order, I recommend that the HDC defer the minutes of November 6, 2006 .”
Certificate of Approval
- HAWP-48D – Applicant: Joseph LaVoie, 5 Walker Avenue, Tree Removal
Background Material (pdf format)
Approved 4-0
- HAWP-13B – Applicant: Glen Todd, 7 Brookes Avenue
Background Material (pdf format)
Approved 4-0
- HAWP-78E – Applicant: Warren and Liz Johnson, 104 Chestnut Street, Driveway Removal/Replacement
Background Material (pdf format)
Approved 4-0
FROM THE ASSISTANT CITY MANAGERS, CITY ATTORNEY AND OTHER STAFF
- Guidance on Drafting Ordinance Concerning the Installation of Automated Sprinkler Systems in Vacant Multi-Family Residential Dwellings
Background Material (pdf format)
Directed staff to introduce proposed ordinance.
- Guidance on Reopening the Mayor and City Council Record on T-377 – Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance
Background Material (pdf format)
Vote 3-0 to reopen record to receive Planning Commission recommendation and any additional comments from the public, until Nov. 22, 2006 , 5 p.m.
- Guidance on Proposed Text Amendment - Indoor Aquatic Facility at the GE Tech Park Site
Background Material (pdf format)
Directed staff to introduce proposed ordinance.